Gundam: G no Reconguista – 19

gun191

After watching this week’s installment of Gundam, Zane came into the office with his hands in the air, as if to surrender. “There’s not even anything of note to make fun of here. At this point it’s just kind of sad,” he said, telling me if he wanted a review I’d have to do it myself.

gun192

So here I am, reluctantly closing the RABUJOI book on Gundam: G no Reconguista after nineteen straight episodes of lovely visuals, some clever sci-fi procedural action, and slice-of-life unfortunately combined with impenetrable storytelling and an abject lack of emotional connection on all fronts.

gun193

There’s a clear retro flavor to the way everyone talks and relates to each other, and I’m sure there’s an audience that enjoys that kind of thing, but to me, it just feels like a lot of the material was written for a bad radio serial fifty years ago, and is now being re-used with updated animation, and it’s just never felt right.

gun194

The show shows us all these lives, but never lets us into their heads, and even when they speak their thoughts out loud, the words feel hollow and inconsequential. The music attempts to create lightheartedness or drama that simply hasn’t been earned by the story, or even attempted to be earned.

gun195

Gundam G-Recon often feels like an animated documentary, which has cameras and mics in everyone’s faces, but nobody explaining what’s going on or why. We are neutral observers, and the stuff being observed is utterly incapable of truly moving us. It’s content to march along to the beat of its own drummer, and you either get in step or walk away.

gun196

That’s mostly because events and introductions often feel random and tacked on for no other reason to make the story and the character dynamics more complex, but no amount of complexity—or kooky group of mercenaries from the Venus Globe—can fix the show’s underlying flaws.

gun197

This is not a terrible show. It’s clearly created by people in love with this universe; its large-scale issues and smaller minutiae alike. It also makes some salient points about space travel, battle, maintenance, and national pride. Its visuals and character and mechanical design are top-notch; and its soundtrack is usually stellar.

gun199

But all those factors merely contribute to my respect for this work. They have yet to garner my love, and without love or any other kind of strong emotional investment (beyond that with the franchise itself based on previous, better works), the cons overshadow the pros. And if I don’t love it after nineteen episodes, I shouldn’t be reviewing it. It’s not RABUJOI way, nor is it fair to you the readers.

Farewell Gundam, until the next series.

6_brav2droppedblank

Advertisements

Author: braverade

Hannah Brave is a staff writer for RABUJOI.

3 thoughts on “Gundam: G no Reconguista – 19”

  1. Man, this is just disappointing. Even the much maligned Seed Destiny (just Destiny, Seed is arguably one of the best entries of the franchise) had a more coherent story than this *notwithstanding what you feel about the last third of that series).

    There’s a clear retro flavor to the way everyone talks and relates to each other, and I’m sure there’s an audience that enjoys that kind of thing, but to me,it just feels like stuff that was written fifty years ago is being re-used with updated animation, and it’s just never felt right.

    I don’t mind the 50’s speak (hey, I am a big fan of classics from that era). But what I do mind is the fact that even in the 50’s there are a lot more coherent stories than this. This one, I just don’t even know what Tomino (granted that he is also the one writing it) is trying to pull off.

  2. Oh man, you two win major props for holding out so long. Even my dip into Sega Girls pales in comparison to this epic.

    I think Flamerounin hits it on the head: no one knows what this show is about or trying to be about.

    If it’s an adventure, we have no clue where it’s going now (since the destination and enemies have changed a few times)

    If it’s a comedy/kids have fun in space throw away, we have too many characters who act too weirdly and are unlikeable AND the humor is less funny than the unintentionally ridiculous dialog.

    If it’s a drama… we probably need simpler, clearly stated stakes or more of a sense of risk for our heroes, who have yet to face anything remotely challenging from the villains.

    blargh but who knows what this is supposed to be? Almost 10 hours for sure and Hanna/Zane get credit for surviving that.

  3. It was a bit of mess but i had fun. I think a lot of it problems come from having a 73 year old man try and write, storyboard and direct all by himself. Still have have a lot of respect for the man though, Tomino has a lot of interesting ideas but he needs help when trying to fit it into a cohesive story. There were a lot of talented people working on this though and its absolutely gorgeous, It would be nice to see the visual team get back together to work on something else one day I need more shows with yoshida character designs. Also I’m pleased that ippei gyoubu is doing a few designs for iron blooded orphans.

Comments are closed.