Vinland Saga S2 – 09 – Climb of Atonement

It was all a dream. So thinks a clean-shaven Thorfinn, lounging in a grassy meadow when a lamb wakes him. Uemura Yuuto voices this carefree version of him in a way we’ve never heard Thorfinn speak, or if we have, it was so long ago he might as well have been a different person. In reality, Einar is just finishing up a fight with the retainers that he wins, because he won’t stop getting back up and his opponents are tired of fighting.

Thorfinn’s dream turns quickly when his father Thors appears and says he smells blood. Thorfinn looks down to find the dagger Thors gave him for protection thrust into the neck of a young Einar, who transforms into the older Einar he knows. As corpses sprout out of the ground to grab the father and son, it is only the son who falls through the resulting fissure. Before he falls, Thors repeats the philosophy he held to until his death: nobody has any enemies, so there is no worth in hurting others.

Thorfinn’s drop is long and painful as he continually smacks against the sharp stone walls. It takes most of his fingernails, but he manages gain a grip just before falling off an edge into what looks like the nether-regions of hell. MAPPA really goes all out with the nightmare fuel here. Askeladd is there, and he’s still himself. This is not Valhalla. Instead, it’s where fallen warriors really go: to fight a pointless, everlasting battle…and laugh.

As Thorfinn’s grip begins to fail, a column of ghouls reach him and start to grab his feet. Askeladd tells him to stop kicking them and listen to their complaints, for they are all the people he has killed. Thorfinn starts to shed tears and apologizes to them. When ghouls down below start firing arrows, Askeladd jumps down and fights them, then tells Thorfinn to start climbing, taking those he killed with him. That is his true battle.

With a gut-wrenching cry of determination, Thorfinn stretches and reaches upward, and suddenly finds himself propelled all the way back to Ketil’s farm, under a cloudy but open sky. He’s awake, and Einar is alive. As he lends a hand taking Einar back to their barn, Thorfinn once again weeps, telling Einar he’s renouncing violence from now on. Even waking up a slave on a ravaged farm with punishment on the way for the brawl is preferable to that nightmare land he experienced.

Only, thanks to Pater, there is no punishment for Thorfinn or Einar. He found a button from one of the retainer’s coats on the ravaged farm, and decides that the face-saving story will be that wild boars ruined it. The retainer submits to his master’s wishes, and Sverkel oversees Thorfinn and Einar re-hoeing the land his son gave them. Like his father, Thorfinn has turned a page in his life. That punch was his last, his warring days done; he is reborn a new, better man. No longer a taker, but a maker.

In / Spectre – 21 – Clearing the Air

Of the three Otonashi family members gathered, Rion (voiced by Iwami Manaka) is the only one whose thoughts we’re privy to. She rightfully wonders just what the hell she’s gotten into, and also realizes she’s underdressed for the occasion. Kotoko breaks the ice with another vulgar remark involving her an Kurou, before leaving the three to decide on an a singular narrative for how the president murdered Sumi, and a mutually agreed-upon order of inheritance.

It takes Susumu, Kouya, and Rion less than three minutes to come to an agreement, which is so fast that Kotoko wonders if it’s an agreement that they came upon in advance. She then reiterates that both the president, his sons, his daughter, and her fiance all had cause to murder her, but since everyone had solid alibis and no further evidence, her death was deemed a random burglary and murder.

Rion picks up on the semi-accusatory tone as Kotoko describes the ways Sumi’s children’s alibis were all too convenient, timely, and fortunate—even her daughter Kaoruko breaking her leg. Kotoko further prods her by calling the theorizing entertaining. Rion speaks up for her older relatives, telling Kotoko she’s completely devoid of taste. In this moment I felt bad for Rion, because I knew Kotoko was so many steps ahead.

Kotoko makes clear that the president was adamant that “the crime get the proper punishment”. This is the opportunity for everyone assembled to come clean, and Susumu is the first to avail himself of that opportunity. To Rion’s shock, both he and her father Ryouma plotted to kill their mother, but someone simply beat them to it, while they were still planning. While Rion points out that her uncle and dad hated each other, they also both standed to gain from Sumi’s death, so they collaborated on a murder plot while remaining at odds about everything else.

Susumu even posits that his brother sent Rion to the meeting in his place so she’d learn of the crime, as a way of atonement. Before Rion can catch her breath, Kotoko gently prods Kouya, who also confesses that he and Kaoruko also plotted to murder Sumi so they could get married. The plan involved Kaoruko pretending to break her leg for the alibi, only to break it for real before she could do the deed.

Now that “the sins of the successors” have come to light, Susumu believes they’re all done there. But Kotoko doesn’t care about their past sins. She’s there to hear them give their explanation for how the president managed to murder Sumi before any of them could. She assumed that all the secrets flying around would disorient Rion, so thought it best to take care of all of those first, and then give everyone a chance to arrive upon a satisfying answer.

In effect, Kotoko proves that she is not someone to be trifled with, as she played everyone in the room like a fiddle. Everyone except Rion, the sole innocent, to whom Kotoko helped reveal her family’s dark secrets. Rion seems like an otherwise easygoing person who didn’t mind being ranked last in the inheritance. Will that change now that she knows the truth?