Fate / stay night gave us another breather between battles this week. Nothing major was revealed, nor did the Emiya/Rin alliance determine what, if any strategy they would pursue in hunting down Caster.
In fact, while Archer gives us a sliver more info on Emiya’s new secondary projection magic ability, I would argue the explanation is so vague and obviously loaded with unsaid implications about Archer’s own back story, that this episode raises more questions than answers.
To sum up: Behind his casual smile, Emiya is on the ropes. Using his new ability has put the left half of his body into shock and upset his balance. Physical pain aside, he’s become clumsy and weak, breaking dishes and even struggling to hold an eraser.
However, it’s not until late in the episode that Saber and Rin start to catch on, and then, only Archer’s sudden arrival offers a solution. See, Archer claims this happened to him, during his own life, and he quickly sets Emiya on the mend. Cold as ever, he doesn’t explain any more than that but, on the up side, he says Emiya will most likely be a significantly stronger mage after a few days of recovery.
In non-Emiya news, we got a lot more RIn this week and, despite some tsundere flame-ups over Emiya’s emotional density, we even got a lot more emotional range from her too. Her chat with Emiya about the differences between the houses they live in, and how that mood translates into the types of people they are was quite pleasant.
Otherwise? Ninja-sensei is dodging school, as expected. Sensei-chan is nagging, pesky, and easily defeated by Rin. Sakura, Shinji, and everyone else of note remain unseen…
The Good: if you ignore Rin’s tsundere moment at the end of her conversation with Emiya, her scenes were very good this week. It was especially nice to see more of her and Saber getting along. The girls are really in sync and, in their own way, so are Archer and Emiya.
This is an interesting direction for the show to go in and I’m curious to see if we ever learn that Rin really should have summoned Saber and Emiya Archer, but some outside force prevented this. Despite their conflicts, Emiya is constantly emulating Archer and, after Archer helps Emiya at the end of this episode, and after Archer yells at him about his ideals, it really seems like Archer sees a lot of himself — his mistakes — in Emiya.
The not so good: Sensei-chan is a dull anime trope. While it was fun to see Rin take her apart in verbal sparing, Sensei is so unimportant to the story, and so immature, Rin’s victory doesn’t hold much meaning.
Furthermore, if we have time to waste on fluff like Sensei-chan, the complete lack of Lancer/Berserker/Shinji or anyone who would scoot the broader story along is frustrating.
The Verdict: I can’t help but think that I’m stuck watching the ‘dumb teenagers,’ who don’t know what they are doing or what is going on, while a much more interesting anime is going on around them. Obviously, these dumb kids will become the most successful and/or ‘win’ the day, and seeing their development into winners is the point but… I do feel like the show has spread out the opponents’ appearances too much.
I mean, we haven’t seen Lancer in 8-9 episodes!
As many have mentioned in the comments, this show suffers from trying to capture all of the unrelatable threads of an interactive fiction into an ordered fiction. It does a very good job under those constraints, it’s visually stunning, and Emiya is finally developing as a character.
More importantly, Rin got much needed screen time and it wasn’t all one note. All together, it was a great episode, certainly miles above average for a chapter bridge. Still, I can’t help but feel Rin doesn’t get enough screen time, or isn’t written well enough to get more…