As Madoka continues to weigh whether she should become a Majo Shojo for a surprising fifth week, Sayaka reaps the benefits of doing so right away, as her friend is able to play the violin beautifully like nothing ever happened. But the price of doing what Sayaka did, according to Homura, is too high. She tells Madoka she can’t protect Sayaka, and she should give up on her.
Majo Shojos all seem to be resigned to losing their lives at any moment, because, as Mimi demonstrated, they can. Contracting with Kyubei is almost like dying itself; you just stick around to fight witches until you have a bad day, and then, pfft. I can understand Madoka’s reticence, especially since her wish isn’t as specific or clear-cut as Sayaka’s was.
Madoka obviously wants to protect Sayaka, but that isn’t a wish. Furthermore, when a new, hardened Majo Shojo appears and tries to shoo Sayaka off, provoking her into a duel against one another, Madoka is moments from contracting when Homura shows up, to do just what she said she wouldn’t: keep an eye on Sayaka. She must really not want Madoka to become a Majo Shojo. Perhaps she knows, somehow, that if she did, there’d be no stopping her. Rating: 3.5